Good ideas get legs and run. It appears that “self-destructing” TODO comments is a good idea, because the concept has now been implemented in Rust, Ruby, Python, and Elixir (as a credo check). Here’s some insight on that decision shared by the package author, Brian Underwood:

I talked with a couple of other people on the Elixir Slack about it when I started and we all liked the idea of doing it as a check (like with credo) as opposed to at runtime because that could fail on production (not very with the “stability” Elixir ethos 😅).

Compile time would be better, but if you wanted to implement something like the check of GitHub issues then you’re adding HTTP requests to your application’s compile, which maybe means that you’re app doesn’t compile if the HTTP request fails (like because GitHub is down, even if the issue isn’t closed yet).